5 & 5: Blue Jackets allow 5 to Islanders, suffer 5th straight loss

Tuesday, November 16, 2026
By Ed Francis
efrancis@cbussports.com

CBJ's Zach Werenski skates

Zach Werenski scored the Columbus Blue Jackets lone goal against the New York Islanders at UBS Arena on Tuesday. Photo: Kevin Lam

CBJ scorebug graphic

The Columbus Blue Jackets suffered their fifth consecutive regulation loss Tuesday night, falling 5-1 to the New York Islanders at UBS Arena.

Zach Werenski scored the lone goal for Columbus and goalie Cam Talbot made 36 saves in the losing effort.

Islanders rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer recorded his first career hat trick, becoming the first New York defenseman to accomplish the feat since Denis Potvin in 1982.

Anthony Duclair opened the scoring with a power-play goal late in the first period before Schaefer doubled the Islanders’ lead early in the second.

Werenski gave Columbus life just 1:12 into the third period to cut the deficit to 2-1.

However, in a familiar story this season, the Blue Jackets couldn’t capitalize on the momentum.

Schaefer restored New York’s two-goal advantage at 7:01 on a goal that the Blue Jackets challenged for goaltender interference, but the goal stood following video review.

Tony DeAngelo made it 4-1 less than five minutes later before Schaefer completed his hat trick with an empty-net goal.

Ilya Sorokin finished with 28 saves for New York, which has now won three straight games.

Columbus has now been outscored 16-6 over its last four games, with its offensive struggles continuing to leave little margin for error.

Don Granato, who remains the Blue Jackets’ acting coach with Rick Bowness away for health reasons, chalked the loss up to one key thing.

“We got away from our structure again,” he said. “We didn’t have a great start. We were able to stay in it. We turned some momentum back, and then some decisions in the second period, it just allowed the game to open up and get excitement and energy in this building for (the Islanders).”

Here’s how the Blue Jackets started the four-game road trip in losing fashion:

NYI: 1, CBJ: 0 (1ST PERIOD, 0:58 REMAINING)

The Islanders capitalize on a power play late in the first. DeAngelo controls the puck at the left point before passing to Anthony Duclair, who moves it to Mathew Barzal near the right circle. Barzal quickly returns the puck to Duclair in the high slot, where he fires a wrist shot past Talbot’s glove to make it a 1-0 Islanders game heading into the first intermission.

NYI: 2, CBJ: 0 (2ND PERIOD, 18:26 REMAINING)

The Islanders double their lead early in the second period. A loose puck finds Matthew Schaefer above the right circle, where the rookie defenseman takes advantage of Cam Talbot being down on the ice and fires a shot past his glove. The goal puts Columbus in a 2-0 hole just 1:34 into the period.

NYI: 2, CBJ: 1 (3RD PERIOD, 18:48 REMAINING)

The Blue Jackets cut the deficit in half just 1:12 into the third. Werenski carries the puck down the left wing, skating past Ryan Pulock before cutting across the crease. Werenski then slides a backhand underneath Sorokin’s right pad to get Columbus on the board for the only time in the game.

NYI: 3, CBJ: 1 (3RD PERIOD, 12:59 REMAINING)

The Islanders regain their two-goal lead just minutes after Columbus gets on the board. Pulock fires a slap shot from the right point that Talbot initially stops, but the rebound kicks out to Schaefer near the left hash marks. Schaefer quickly backhands the loose puck into the open net for his second goal of the night.

NYI: 4, CBJ: 1 (3RD PERIOD, 8:08 REMAINING)

The Islanders extend their lead to three goals midway through the third period. Barzal leaves a drop pass for DeAngelo along the boards, and the defenseman easily skates toward the crease before lifting a backhand over Talbot’s blocker. The goal puts New York ahead 4-1 and essentially puts this one out of reach.

NYI: 5, CBJ: 1 (3RD PERIOD, 3:52 REMAINING)

The empty-netter gives Schaefer his hat trick. He takes the puck near center-ice and flips it down and into the net, sending hats flying onto the UBS Arena ice.

QUICK THOUGHTS: It’s not even a surprise anymore: another game, another frustrating offensive performance from the Blue Jackets. It’s hard to win games when you’re consistently struggling to put the puck in the net, and that’s exactly where Columbus finds itself right now. Yeah, they gave up four (plus an empty-netter). But this was a 2-1 game in the third period and even at that point, it never felt like this team would be able to pull it out because they simply can’t score. Six goals over their last four games tells the whole story.

NEXT UP: Game two of the four-game road trip is Thursday night against the Chicago Blackhawks. Puck-drop is 8:00 p.m. at United Center.