Boys soccer: St. Charles falls to Fairmont in Division I state title pursuit
Sunday, November 15, 2026
By Michael Rich
mrichnotwealthy@gmail.com
St. Charles’ A.J. Boiarsky looks to pass during the Cardinals’ state title game with Kettering Fairmont Sunday at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field. The Firebirds won 3-1. Photo: Kevin Rouch
COLUMBUS – It’s hard to win a state championship. Just ask the St. Charles boys soccer team.
The Cardinals had to fight on and off the field to get to the Division I state final. Ultimately, they came up short.
Azariyah Nsabimana had a goal and an assist to lead Kettering Fairmont to a 3-1 victory to win their first state championship on Nov. 15 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.
“These guys work harder than anyone else,” Cardinals senior midfielder A.J. Boiarsky said. “We came in in the summer, we were here at 5:45 each morning to get ready for lifting, out (practicing) after school, not getting home until 8 or 9 p.m. These guys work so hard and to come up short … is heartbreaking.”
St. Charles was originally assigned to Division II. In previous seasons, school administration had submitted paperwork to move up to Division I for soccer.
This season, the administration missed the deadline, and the Cardinals were placed in Division II.
It took an injunction to allow St. Charles to participate in Division I just as it had the previous season. And the season before that. And the season before that.
St. Charles’ Tyler Bushong and Fairmont’s Noah Baumgarten (3) go flying after colliding during their Division I state championship game on Sunday in Columbus. Photo: Kevin Rouch
Yes, St. Charles, a program that has advanced to the state tournament in four consecutive seasons, achieved that in Division I despite a student population that would otherwise put it in Division II.
“I don’t want to take anything away from Fairmont with these comments,” St. Charles coach Chris Vonau said. “But what these guys had to go through. Respectfully, the climb that we’ve had to (make) is unlike any other climb I’ve witnessed.
Not once did they lose faith and not once did they be divisive – or stop listening. In the midst of unthinkable turmoil for high school kids, they battled, they grind and they didn’t once stop. I’m crazy appreciative (of them).”
But none of that was on the athletes. The 10th circuit court didn’t officiate their match against Fairmont.
“We weren’t even supposed to be here – we’re supposed to be in Division II,” Boiarsky said. “And we’re in Division I. We weren’t supposed to get this far. That meant a lot to us.”
The Cardinals were in the state tournament for the 12th time overall and have finished second six times, most recently in 2024.
They attempted to do something not done since Doc Brown solved time travel in 1985.
St. Charles (18-4-1) had more opportunities – a 23-8 advantage in shots and eight corner kick tries to just two for Fairmont.
St. Charles’ McLean Hulme (7) goes on the attack against Fairmont’s Gavin Weaver during their state championship game on Sunday at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field in Columbus. Photo: Kevin Rouch
Despite that, Nsabimana scored in the 11th minute to give the Firebirds the lead and then found Aaron Black in the 23rd minute for what turned out to be the game-winner.
Sam Lofthouse received Ethan Bush’s throw-in, did a 180-degree turn and scored in the 54th minute to cut the Cardinals deficit to one.
But less than four minutes later, Gavin Weaver found Luke Davidson for an answering goal and Fairmont had its breathing room again.
Firebirds goalie Carson Dewald had six saves and Micah Neal stopped three shots in goal for the Cardinals.
Fairmont (15-5-3) had a tail of three seasons. The Firebirds went undefeated in their first eight games (6-0-2) only to go winless over the next six (0-5-1).
With the win, Fairmont closes the season with eight consecutive wins.
“The whole tournament road wasn’t just about a state final game,” said Black, a senior midfielder. “Really, every game was just about looking for four more days with my brothers. So, this is just the end of the road.
“It’s amazing to walk away with this (medal) and eventually a ring. But the whole point was I wanted four more days. And to see that we maxed out the amount of days we had is just really special.”
St. Charles’ Sam Lofthouse (left) elevates with Fairmont goalkeeper Carson Dewald during the OHSAA Division I state title game on Sunday in Columbus. Photo: Kevin Rouch