Boys soccer: Watterson overcomes Carroll fury to repeat as Division III state champs

Monday, November 16, 2026
By Michael Rich
mrichnotwealthy@gmail.com

Watterson boys soccer team with state championship trophy

The Watterson Eagles pose with their OHSAA state championship trophy after defeating the Archbishop Carroll Patriots 2-1 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field on Monday. Photo: Kevin Rouch

COLUMBUS – Sam Meacham wasn’t completely sure where the ball was going when he released his shot. But the ball ended up exactly where the senior midfielder hoped it would on Nov. 16 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.

Meacham’s odd-angle goal from low on the right in the 71st minute ended up being the difference in the Watterson boys soccer team’s 2-1 win over Dayton Carroll in the Division III state title game.

The Eagles are champions for the second time in as many seasons and second overall.

“Logan (Bills) beat two or three guys and he just passed it and it kind of came right to me,” Meacham said. “I just shot it. I had no hope of it going in, but it just snuck by the goalie (Carroll’s Gabe Memering).

“I thought it was going right of the goal and then it just snuck in there barely at the right time.”

It was a shot that emulated Watterson’s whole experience. Carroll (23-1-1) is like watching the Tasmanian Devil on three cases of Red Bull.

Watterson's Logan Bills pass for assist

Watterson’s Logan Bills (11) sends a pass that would allow teammate Sam Meacham to score the winning goal against Carroll on Monday at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field. Photo: Kevin Rouch

“That was one of the funnest games I’ve been a part of,” Watterson coach Aaron Linden said. “We knew going in that it was going to be tough – they were undefeated for a reason. It was a blast.

“It was just so fun seeing these guys come back – granted we were never down – but just seeing what we did. My hats off to Dayton Carroll – they were fantastic.”

The Eagles never trailed, it just felt that way.

Watterson (20-3-1) took a 1-0 lead on Matthew Staravecka’s goal in front after a perfectly placed centering pass from Josh Schultheis in the 34th minute.

The Eagles held the advantage in shots (18-13), shots on goal (8-4) and corner kick opportunities (7-2), but had little to show for it.

Watterson goalie Aedan Richardson made all seven of his saves in the second half.

“I think we’re relentless at times – just on top of people,” Carroll coach Scott Molfenter said. “We don’t let them move, and we’re going to jump on mistakes and capitalize.

Watterson's Sid Hunt with contested kick

Watterson’s Sid Hunt (21) shoots at the top of the box against Carroll’s Luis Wagner during the teams’ OHSAA Division III state title game in Columbus on Monday. Photo: Kevin Rouch

“The biggest thing is that we don’t just want to keep the ball, we want to keep the ball with authority and create chances. Everybody on our teams knows they have the green light. So, this group’s been a blessing to work with.”

Carroll, which was second behind Watterson in MaxPreps latest rankings, tied the game in the 55th minute when Luis Wagner put in a loose ball in front into the back of the net.

But it was the only goal they were able to get despite the flurry of chances in the second half.

“I thought we had a challenging run to get here. We played a lot of minutes,” Molfenter said. “We just couldn’t find the back of the net. I thought we played a fantastic game.”

Alex Bakota had a game-high seven shots and four shots on goal for the Patriots.

“It was definitely a tough game,” senior defender Grayson Davis said. “We played to our strengths. They play direct well, but I feel like we weathered the storm good.”

Watterson's Josh Schultheis with header

Watterson’s Josh Schultheis (1) with the header against Carroll’s Luis Wagner during the Eagles’ state title win on Monday at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field. Photo: Kevin Rouch