Girls wrestling: Brokaw, Carder, Tibbs shine at state tournament
Monday, March 16, 2026
By Michael Rich
mrichnotwealthy@gmail.com
Gahanna’s KyLee Tibbs celebrates her second state wrestling title at Ohio State’s Schottenstein Center Sunday. Photo: John Hulkenberg
Mackenzie Carder is a state champion and she’s excited about it. She promises.
After twice finishing as runner up, the junior had her hand raised after defeating friend and rival Cami Leng at 120 pounds at the girls state wrestling tournament.
Held for the fourth time as an OHSAA-sanctioned sport, the event ran March 13-15 at the Schottenstein Center.
Carder joined Mount Vernon’s Ashlynn Brokaw and Gahanna’s KyLee Tibbs as state champions. It was the second individual title for Brokaw and Tibbs, who are both juniors.
A stoic Carder stood with her hand raised in the middle of the circle following a 14-4 major decision that clinched gold. There was no fist pump, nor did she let out a scream or run around or dance.
“I’m more of a process stuff later kind of person. I don’t know, maybe I need to work on that,” said Carder, who finished 46-2. “I was just excited. It’s cool seeing the whole arena, so (I was) just soaking it all in – looking around, seeing who I could recognize.”
The pressure to capture gold is enormous. Carder finished second at 110 as a freshman and second at 120 last season.
“I think the difference with her this year is that she’s really kept a peaceful mind with her match prep,” Orange coach Brian Nicola said. “She’s really trying to not make the result the whole point. So, in her (preparation), she was very peaceful. She spent today just kind of relaxing and getting her mind right. When you do everything you need to and (prepare) yourself, you’re ready to go.”
Olentangy Orange’s Mackenzie Carder (right) wrestles against Marysville’s Cami Leng at Ohio State Sunday. Carder’s victory allowed her to become the first Pioneer to win a girls’ individual OHSAA state title. Photo: John Hulkenberg
Carder and Leng are teammates in club with Team Miron.
“Nobody likes wrestling their teammate and friend, but she pushes me a lot in the practice gym along with my (Orange teammates) Lacie Knick and Chloe (Tompkins) and Sarah Amonette,” Carder said. “I’m just so grateful to have all these people to help push me and help me work.”
Carder was one of four Pioneers to place, including Knick (third, 130), Tara Davis (fifth, 145) and Tamia Davis (seventh, 155). Orange led area teams with a third-place finish as a team, scoring 70.5 points to finish behind Massillon Perry (83) and Harrison (71.5). The Pioneers won the title last season despite having no individual champions. Marysville (59) was fourth, Gahanna (47.5) fifth and Hartley (32) eighth.
Tibbs’ reaction to her second state title was the opposite of Carder’s. Her emotions were on full display after defeating Archbold’s Vivienne Legato by pin in the 155 final.
“I think it was because of the pressure I felt this entire season to bring it home again,” she said. “The first time, I was coming back from a second-place finish and that drove me. I think this year, the pressure drove me. It was amazing. I knew how much my parents believed in me. My dad (Jeffrey) as my coach and my other coaches (and) how much they pushed me to get to this spot, and it was amazing.”
Tibbs finished 44-2 after moving up a couple of weight classes after winning at 140 last year and finishing second there as a sophomore.
Mount Vernon’s Ashlynn Brokaw (left) competes with Warren’s Emma Gorrell during the OHSAA state championships Sunday at Ohio State. Brokaw won her second title. Photo: John Hulkenberg
Ashlynn Brokaw can relate to Tibbs’ pressure to repeat. Brokaw defeated Vincent Warren’s Emma Gorrell by 13-4 major decision at 115 pounds.
“I kind of just focused on what I needed to improve on,” Brokaw said. “I definitely improved on my footwork, my offense and I’ve just gotten better at my mental focus, in general. I think I’ve gained a whole new level of being able to not worry about the crowd and everybody around me.”
Brokaw took solace in that she’s been in this position before. Wrestling at 105 the last two years, she won a title last year and finished third as a freshman.
“I knew what it was like going through the tunnel – the crowd, everything,” she said. “(I knew) how to calm my nerves down and be mentally prepared for this finals match. I think that really helped me a lot.”
Brokaw, who finished 44-2, is coached by her dad, Jay DePolo.
“She’s going to put in the work – we don’t have to worry about that,” he said. “Our coaching staff (and) our wrestling family has just been super supportive. The whole community supported her. I think that helps.
“On the flip side of that, that also adds pressure to live up to that expectation. She’s always one that rises to the occasion and peaks at the right time. And I think she did that (this weekend).”
There is a line of demarcation in the household. Brokaw and DePolo try not to discuss wrestling at home.
“Sometimes we butt heads, but I would have it any other way,” Brokaw said. “I think having him so closely tied to me has helped a lot. My sister is there to support me and she helps me a lot. (She) pushes me through the times where I don’t think I can do it.”
Olentangy Orange coaches Vanessa Oswalt and Brian Nicola watch the action at the OHSAA state wrestling championships at Ohio State Sunday. Photo: John Hulkenberg
State placers
100: Mila Cruz (Watkins Memorial, third); Kenleigh Ballance (Pickerington North, fifth); Avery Riley (Marysville, seventh)
110: Ashlynn Brokaw (Mount Vernon, first)
115: Reagan Johnson (Thomas Worthington, seventh)
120: Mackenzie Carder (Orange, first); Cami Leng (Marysville, second)
125: Kendleigh Dowalter (Grove City, third); Kara Hockenbery (West Jefferson, eighth)
130: Lacie Knick (Orange, third)
135: Adison Justice (Licking Valley, fourth)
140: Nora Johnson (Hartley, second); Cara Leng (Marysville, fifth)
145: Reese Thomas (Jonathan Alder, second); Tara Davis (Orange, fifth)
155: KyLee Tibbs (Gahanna, first); Maya Keane (Hartley, fifth), Tamia Davis (Orange, seventh)
170: Razilee Wisseh (Canal Winchester, third); Jordan Mills (Gahanna, fifth)
190: Emma Bolton (Highland, seventh)
235: Maci Lee (Marysville, fifth)