Watterson girls soccer falls just short of Division II state title
Saturday, November 14, 2026
By Michael Rich
mrichnotwealthy@gmail.com
Watterson’s Sophie Scott awaits the whistle to begin play against the Hudson Explorers in the Division II state title game at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field on Saturday. Photo: Kevin Rouch
COLUMBUS – The Watterson girls soccer team wore the look of disappointment on their faces after falling in the Division II state championship game. It’s understandable.
But there is joy even in defeat.
The Eagles couldn’t keep up with Hudson on Nov. 14 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field, dropping a 2-0 decision.
Watterson went up against a team that played its best game at the right time to cap off an undefeated season.
The Explorers (22-0) scored twice in the last 22 minutes to claim their first championship since 2000 and second overall.
“They’re a really smart team,” Watterson junior forward Sophie Scott said. “They combine really well and they’re super fast. It’s really fun playing against them. They’re a very competitive team. I feel we matched their intensity.”
The game appeared one-sided on the stat sheet. Hudson had an 18-4 advantage in shots, holding Watterson blank in that category in the first half.
Watterson goalkeeper Josie Smith (center) elevates to make a save during the Eagles’ state championship tilt against Hudson on Saturday. Photo: Kevin Rouch
“I knew coming in that Bishop Watterson was going to be difficult – breaking down their defense was going to be hard,” Hudson coach Josh Huettich said. “Just being able to overcome that was fantastic.
“But really, I would like to equally (give) credit to our girls … (they) literally saved the best game of their entire season for today.”
Ella Gresh lifted a ball perfectly over Watterson goalie Josie Smith in the 58th minute to put the Explorers up 1-0.
Then, Hannah Meese put the game out of reach, sliding a ball left to right for a goal in the 73rd minute.
Even before that Hudson looked poised to take the lead. In the 27th minute, Maniar broke free through the middle with just Smith in sight.
But out of nowhere Watterson defender Stella Schiavone cut her off, knocking the ball away.
Hudson didn’t get its first shot on goal until the 50th minute when Smith stopped another Maniar breakaway. Smith finished with two saves.
Watterson’s Stella Schiavone brings the ball up the pitch during the Eagles’ game against the Hudson Explorers at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field on Saturday. Photo: Kevin Rouch
“I don’t feel like our team let down for a second,” said Eagles coach Scott Dempsey, whose team was playing in their third consecutive state tournament. “The game could turn at any point in little moments. … And that’s how the game turned out.”
Meese and Allyssa Maniar each had six shots to lead the Explorers, who defeated Watterson by the same score in last year’s state semifinal.
“We had been here before, so there was a lot more comfort going into it,” Hudson senior midfielder Abby Filipovitz said. “In the locker room, we were (doing things) to lift each other up. We just came in more prepared and a lot more calm. It was a really fun experience, and I think it made the game fun.”
Watterson had just two shots on goal, both by Scott and both saved by Hudson goalie Addie Frank.
“We love competing with each other in practice,” Scott said. “We were so blessed to get to compete at the highest level tonight. And to be able to do that with my friends, who I call sisters, is just such a blessing.”
Watterson’s Stella Mauro (9) protects the ball as she battles with Hudson’s Sejal Bhatia on the end line at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field on Saturday. Photo: Kevin Rouch